Friday, March 20, 2009

Response: The American Prospect

Foot in mouth? Well, maybe a little. I guess I was kind of on a "these Republicans make sense!" high and didn't really look to see what they were pushing for. Now that I know their bargaining points and where they would have the state of the country be, I think I might love them a little less. But that's okay! They're still needed. They're still not flamingly out there. So, while I can be glad they're not majority, I am still glad of their presence. Their opinions are not mine, nor necessarily those of the majority party and that's okay. They are willing to negotiate with the left (and the right) and play the mediator position that we need. While their ideas might not be ones I'd want in full control, my ideas are not those others would want in full control. So, yes, moderates are still necessary. This opinion has more validity now because I have scene the opinions of theirs and, yes, I disagree, to a certain extent, to them. I have scene what the Liberal's say about what the moderate Republicans are pushing for, what I will next look for is the moderates' own thoughts on their actions.

Wednesday, March 18, 2009

NOTES: The American Prospect

Republicans divided over budget - will they argue or will they come up with some alternative solution.
Senate is bent on arguing, whereas the house is looking for alternatives.
Moderate Republicans who will work with Democrats have a ton of power 
Moderates don't:
have a plan to increase revenue other than cutting necessary program such as Medicare and Social Security
want to deal with global warming
have ideas for health care reform
want to cut spending in the student loan area and agribusiness
They are opposed to more spending to keep the financial folk afloat. 
These ideas, combined and put into a bill would a) still mess with the defecit and b) not help the concerns of the public.
In the House, Republicans are powerless because of the majority.
Dave Wiegel: "Minority status means never having to explain what the ---- you're talking about."
House Republicans can use whatever (incorrect or correct) evidence to back their ideas because, in the strictly voting scheme of things, they don't matter.
"Meanwhile, in the Senate, the moderate Republicans are going to have to walk their talk, and know that their ideal budget is both politically unpopular and fiscally irresponsible."

Thursday, March 5, 2009

RESPONSE: A Moderate Manifesto

A moderate conservative! Who writes for the New York Times! What more could a girl want in her research?

Sometimes, in my verbal support of moderates, I forget that they don't necessarily like and believe what I like and believe. For instance: No one needs to make millions of dollars a year. Is it not sensical that those with the greatest ability to pay would be taxed greater? Can you expect someone getting minimum wage to take the same hit to their income a CEO? As much as I think a dicatorship under me would be utopia (kidding, kidding) I need to remember that not everybody thinks the way I do. And the things I think are right are not right for everybody. This I must remind myself.

Okay, now that I kind of got my discrepencies out of the way, I am glad that moderates see it fit to be influential in government. Too often, it seems, they have stepped back or been outspoken when big issues have come up that could have used their moderation (sorry for the pun). Particularly in our current situation, their rarity is almost an asset. Every one of the three Republicans who worked on the stimulus bill now has the respect and attention of the Obama administration. Now, they can be heard without shouting for all they have to fight against is the vague drone of the Limbaugh-ites' complaints, made redundant by endless repetition.

Our nation is one founded on the idea of checks and balances. And when your ideas are those being checked and balanced, well, it's not too fun. But for liberals, who, for eight years, have been the screaming children in Bush administration's back seat, we need to let the change happen. As this article helped me see, Obama cannot be a procurer of change, just as an actor cannot be a procurer of a character. You cannot make something that is not there. Instead, you must enter into the stream of energy, contribute yourself fully, and allow the transformation to happen. This is what Obama must do - commit himself fully but not repel morphing. Otherwise, he will end up no better than his opposition. And while, I honestly would not mind some unchecked Obama, we all must be aware, no matter our bias, that absolute power is never okay. The channel and the ultimate effect is what matters. Who speaks up, be they liberal, conservative, or somewhere in between, matters not. If we want change, we must allow ourselves to be changed.

NOTES: A Moderate Manifesto

Moderate conservatives, moderate liberals, and moderate moderates still exist!
Moderates are supportive of some of Obama's choices such as health care reform, investments in education, and energy innovation.
Some see Obama's choices as unbudgable, not up for compromise, and blatantly partisan.
Liberals are seen as believing passionately in their indisposability.
Moderates are a little terrified by the size of the budget, the potential deficit, and the complete social-reworking that this government is invoking.
Moderates are critical of Obama's concentrated taxation on the upper 5% because of its ability to augment class differentiation.
Moderates also critical of a very centralized government and enormous government spending as a percentage of the GDP.
Moderates feel a little misled - they did not expect such outright liberalism. They are also afraid of what might happen if Obama fails. The nation could slip into the hands of a Republican party not suited for the job.
Moderates are seeing a lack of limited but effective governments and see the need to speak up.
"The first task will be to block the excesses of unchecked liberalism. In the past weeks, Democrats have legislated provisions to dilute welfare reform, restrict the inflow of skilled imigrants and gut a voucher program designed for poor students. It will be up to moderates to raise the alarms against these ideological outrages.
Moderates looking for a nation in which difficulties are shared.
"This is a vision that puts competitiveness and growth first, not redistribution first."
Moderates seeking to ebb Obama's partisan tide.

Final focus: further research needed

As I was writing my essay, I came to the realization that my research lacked the opinions of moderate Republicans on their party's fall from grace. As make the final push in my research, I will look into the political backgrounds of the authors of my chosen articles in order to choose the best possible advocates for the party. My research already contains a substantial amount of outsider (liberal) input so the more conservative viewings should help round out the spectrum. Another thing I am hoping these last articles will provide me is and idea of what the moderates are doing to regain power. As of now, their position is becoming increasingly flimsy with Michael Steele making attempts to create extremists opponents for already established moderate senators. I believe these motives are worth finding out and there is a bit of hope for the party, as a recent poll reports that only 11% of Republicans think Rush Limbaugh is their leader. Then again, far more than 11% of Republicans are of the far right. So whom do they look to? And is there anyone left for the moderates? I hope to find out.